Exactitud y utilidad diagnóstica de la IgM en infecciones por Bartonella henselae / Accuracy and diagnostic utility of IgM in Bartonella henselae infections

Introduction: Laboratory diagnosis of cat scratch disease (CSD) is based on the determination of specific antibodies anti-Bartonella henselae by different techniques. The CDC recommends IgG by immunofluorescent assay (IFA) as the gold standard. Objective: To determine the accuracy and diagnostic utility of anti-B.henselae IgM by IFA for CSD. Material and Methods: Anti-B. henselae IgG was determined in serum of 108 patients with CSD suspicion; in addition, specific IgM was determined separately and blindly by two thoroughly trained laboratory professionals. We calculated sensitivity (S), specificity (Sp), predictive values both positive (PPV) and negative (NPV), and likelihood ratio (LR) for IgM positive (LR +) and negative (LR-). Results: In 37 patients with positive anti-B.henselae IgG, IgM was positive in 16 and negative in 21; in 71 patients with negative IgG, IgM was negative in 69 and positive in 2. Therefore, IgM showed S 43%, E 97%, PPV 88%, NPV 77%, LR (+) 15 and LR (-) 0.58. Conclusions: The results show that a positive IgM supports, but a negative one does not rule out a B. henselae infection. Therefore, IgG should be still considered as the gold standard for the diagnosis of CSD.

Introducción: El diagnóstico de laboratorio de la enfermedad por arañazo de gato (EAG) se basa en la determinación de anticuerpos específicos anti-Bartonella henselae por distintas técnicas. El CDC de E.U.A. recomienda como estándar de oro la IgG mediante inmunofluorescencia (IF). Objetivo: Determinar la exactitud y utilidad diagnóstica de la IgM anti-B. henselae por IF para EAG. Material y Método: En suero de 108 pacientes a quienes se realizó IgG anti-B. henselae por sospecha de EAG, se determinó la presencia de IgM específica, en forma separada y ciega por dos profesionales de laboratorio ampliamente entrenados. Se calculó sensibilidad (S), especificidad (E), valores predictores positivo (VPP) y negativo (VPN) y likelihood ratio (LR) para una IgM positiva (LR+) y negativa (LR-). Resultados: En 37 pacientes con IgG anti-B. henselae positiva, la IgM fue positiva en 16 y negativa en 11; en 71 pacientes con IgG negativa, la IgM fue negativa en 69 y positiva en 2. Por consiguiente, la IgM presentó S 43%, E 97%, VPP 88%, VPN 77%, LR(+) 15 y LR(-) 0,58. Conclusiones: Los resultados sugieren que una IgM positiva apoya el diagnóstico de EAG, pero una negativa no permite descartarlo. Por tanto, la IgG debe seguir considerándose como el estándar de oro para el diagnóstico de infecciones por B. henselae.

Prevalencia de anticuerpos contra Bartonella henselae en niños, en adolescentes y en una población de riesgo ocupacional en Chile / Prevalence of Bartonella henselae antibodies in Chilean children, adolescents and veterinary workers

Background: Bartonella henselae is the causative agent of cat-scratch disease. Aim: To study the seroepidemiology of Bartonella henselae in healthy Chilean children and in a population with occupational risk. Material and methods: Serum IgG antibodies were determined by indirect fluorescence technique in 181 children and adolescents and in 107 technical and professional workers involved in the care of cats. Samples with titers equal to or greater than 64 were considered positive. Results: Twenty four (13.3%) children and 11 (10.3%) occupational risk subjects were seropositive. No significant differences by age and gender were observed. Conclusions: Assuming that seroprevalence indicates level of exposure to Bartonella henselae, these results suggest that this infection is endemic in Chile and, for this reason, the best antibody titer to diagnose acute cat-scratch disease should be higher than the figure recommended by the Centers for Disease Control in the in United States.